Apax Learning Co., Ltd

Instructional Design (ID) vs. Learning Experience Design (LXD): Unpacking the Differences

In the realm of education and training, two key disciplines often come into play: Instructional Design (ID) and Learning Experience Design (LXD). While they share common goals of enhancing learning outcomes, they have distinct approaches and focuses. Let’s delve into the world of ID and LXD to understand their differences and why they matter.

Here is a summary table comparing the differences between Instructional Design (ID) vs. Learning Experience Design (LXD)

Instructional Design (ID) Learning Experience Design (LXD)
The Traditional Foundation A Holistic Approach
Focus on Content Focus on the Learner
Systematic Approach User-Centered Design
Behavioral Objectives Emotional Connection
Formal Education Informal and Blended Learning

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1. What is Instructional Design (ID)? 

Instructional Design is the practice of creating learning experiences that support learning. It use theories and principles of learning, instructional strategies, media and technology, and evaluation methods to create effective and engaging learning experiences for various audiences and contexts.

Here’s what sets ID apart:

  • Focus on Content: ID primarily concentrates on content delivery and knowledge transfer. It aims to present information in a structured and efficient manner. Think of a traditional lecture or a well-organized textbook; that’s instructional design at work. Imagine that a university course where the instructor meticulously organizes lecture notes, assignments, and readings in a clear syllabus. This structured approach to content delivery is an example of Instructional Design.
  • Systematic Approach: ID follows a systematic process of analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation (ADDIE). It’s all about meticulously planning, creating, and assessing learning materials. They start with analyzing learner needs, design the course content and structure, develop the materials, implement it on their platform, and finally evaluate its effectiveness.
  • Behavioral Objectives: In ID, learning objectives often revolve around specific behavioral outcomes. For example, it might aim to ensure that learners can perform a particular task or solve a specific problem such as:  In a corporate training program, the instructional designer sets a clear behavioral objective: “After this training, employees should be able to complete a specific task accurately without errors.”
  • Formal Education: ID is commonly associated with formal education settings, such as schools, colleges, and corporate training programs. It’s ideal for scenarios where structured learning is essential. For instance, a school district employs instructional designers to create standardized curriculum materials for all its schools. These materials are used in formal classroom settings across the district.

2. What is Learning Experience Design (LXD)

Learning Experience Design (LXD) is a process of creating learning experiences that enable the learner to achieve the desired learning outcome in a human-centered and goal-oriented way. It use design thinking methods, user research techniques, user interface design principles, and learning science concepts to understand the needs, preferences, motivations, and emotions of the learners, and to design solutions that are relevant, meaningful, and enjoyable for them.

Here are some of the distinctive features of LXD:

  • Focus on the Learner: LXD places the learner at the center of the design process. It’s all about creating engaging and meaningful learning experiences that resonate with the learners. For example, a language learning app personalizes lessons based on a user’s interests and progress. It adapts to the learner’s pace and preferences, creating a tailored learning experience. This is a personalized online course with interactive elements; that’s LXD in action.
  • User-Centered Design: LXD borrows principles from user experience (UX) and user interface (UI) design. It emphasizes intuitive navigation, aesthetics, and user engagement. Such as an e-commerce website incorporates LXD principles to make it easy for users to navigate, find products, and complete purchases. It employs intuitive design elements, such as clear icons and straightforward menus.
  • Emotional Connection: LXD seeks to establish an emotional connection between the learner and the content. It aims to make learning enjoyable and memorable, fostering a love for lifelong learning. As an illustration that a museum uses LXD to design interactive exhibits that engage visitors emotionally. A specific example is a historical exhibit might include personal stories and immersive experiences that elicit emotional reactions from visitors.
  • Informal and Blended Learning: LXD isn’t limited to formal education. It’s adaptable to informal and blended learning settings, making it suitable for a wide range of contexts. In particular, a professional organization adopts LXD to create an online community where members can share knowledge informally. It encourages peer-to-peer learning and blends formal courses with collaborative discussions.

3. The Common Ground – Learner-Centricity

Although there are many differences between ID and LXD, they also have things in common and are closely linked to each other. It have the common goal that  improving the learning experience. Both aim to help learners acquire knowledge and skills effectively. The key difference lies in their methodologies and the extent to which they embrace technology and learner-centric principles. 

In essence, the choice between ID and LXD depends on your specific learning objectives and the needs of your audience. Consider the context, content, and the type of learners you’re dealing with when deciding which approach to adopt. In some cases, a blend of both ID and LXD principles might offer the best of both worlds, creating a truly enriching learning experience.

Final thought

These two approaches have a lot to offer to the field of education and training, and it can help you create better learning solutions for yourself and others. Whether you are a learner, a teacher, a trainer, or a designer, you can benefit from understanding the differences and similarities between ID and LXD, and how to apply them in your context.

Useful resources

The top  9 tool for developing e-learning

What is e- learnng?